Restaurant Review

In The World of Diners, A Wise Choice

Athena Restaurant
179-35 Hillside Ave., Jamaica

Cuisine: Diner

Hours: Open 24 hours a day

Telephone: 526-7112

Athena Restaurant, a cavernous space with an easygoing atmosphere that has changed little in its 50 years on Hillside Avenue, is a Queens classic.

The Greek and American diner never closes and is a great place to recall an era gone by.

It’s also a microcosm of the borough, not only in terms of race but of lifestyle.

A scruffy white man in his late 40s or early 50s, complete with trench coat, five o’clock shadow and that ‘old Queens’ accent walked in alone the other day and sat down without taking a menu.

“Hey, Gus, you got spinach pies tonight?” the man asked, to which Gus, who has been working at Athena for 20 years now, just shook his head.  “Whaddya got, Gus?  Gimme something good.”

A few minutes later, two young black men in their early 20s, complete with bandanas, baggy jeans and leather motorcycle jackets, came in and sat on two of the restaurant’s chrome and leather stools.

“Hey Gus, I want two pancakes,” one of the men said.  “And a grilled chicken sandwich.  Make it well done.”

In another part of the restaurant, which was almost empty Monday night at 11 p.m. but is bustling during regular meal times, a couple in their 30s had dinner while reading a novel and a newspaper.

The restaurant, named after the Greek goddess of wisdom, is haunted with the spirits of drifters, thinkers and other assorted characters that live idiosyncratic lives but find themselves together in all-night diners.

Athena’s food, like its atmosphere, is classic.  The standard Greek American diner fare is served, with the addition of an Italian menu, including pizza available by the pie or the slice.  Everything is served quickly and piping hot, with no fuss or small talk.  The service is stoic but not unfriendly.

The number of choices at Athena is staggering.  There are over 20 kinds of omelettes, over a dozen kinds of burgers, over 20 kinds of sandwiches, a dozen kinds of salad and a dozen pizza toppings.  There about six different kinds of pasta dishes, and about the same number of Greek choices.

The prices at Athena are also impressive; a filling meal can easily cost less money than at many fast food joints.  Omelettes, served with potatoes, toast and a drink, are between $2.45 and $5.50.  A burger is only $3.25, with the most elaborate version, the Athena Superburger Deluxe, costing only $5.80.  That burger includes mushrooms, sautéed onions and bacon.

Hot open sandwiches, mini-meals with potatoes and vegetables, are $7.  Cold sandwiches are all under $4.50.  For the truly cash-strapped, there’s a sliced egg sandwich for $1.50, and a grilled cheese sandwich for a dollar more.

Anyone wanting to get fancy can get a prime sirloin steak for $13, or a fried seafood platter for $14.

And how does all this stuff taste?  A small sample of the endless menu taken recently inspires a word that may have been used already to describe other aspects of Athena Restaurant.

It’s classic.

Actually, it’s not just classic—it’s great.

The Yankee Bean Soup ($1.50 a cup), served steaming hot in less than a minute, is unbeatable on a cold night.  It’s a thin chili with hearty white beans replacing beef.

The Chicken Gyro Deluxe ($5.50) is a great choice on the Greek menu.  The chicken is prepared in thinly-sliced strips, and there’s a cool, thick yogurt served on the side.  Greek salad, made up of lettuce, tomatoes and a lot of onions diced into cool, hard cubes, is also included.  It’s all set on top of a warm pita, and the taste is unbeatable.

A good choice for desert is the vanilla ice cream shake ($2).  Served in a tall steel shaker big enough to fill two glasses, the shake is cold and sweet, and thin enough to enjoy any of the hot, fillingfoods.

Athena Restaurant is a classic in the fine tradition of Greek American diners.  Don’t miss it.

–Shams Tarek

press-email.gif (919 bytes)